Profile

Courses He Has Taught

Areas of Research

Seminars/Short Workshops

Talks to Learned Bodies

Recent Talks & Workshops
Publications

Reading Room

Cont@ct

 

 

 

 


 



 -  A Closer Look  - 

At love, forgiveness, happiness, sexuality , fear, family life, politics,…

If you were to pick the most precious gifts in life, what would they be?
If you were to rank life’s most important tasks, what would the list look like?
If you were given a chance to get answers to your ten most important questions, what would you ask?
If you needed a blueprint to live life to the full, where would you look?

Many things we worry about do not matter. Some do. A few matter absolutely. This book looks at these essentials.

You can find meaningful answers. You can learn to really live, not just grow older.
 

About the book - and the title

If you were to pick the most precious gifts in life, what would they be? If you were to rank life’s most important tasks, what would the list look like? If you were given a chance to get answers to your ten most important questions, what would you ask? If you needed a blueprint to live life to the full, where would you look?

Do you have moment -  to pause, to look at the things that matter most, to talk of the things that you have most at heart?

This little book is such an attempt. It looks at the questions and experiences that challenged me most in life. Friends tell me - irrespective of age, gender, nationality or religion - that these are the very issues that grip them most. Quite simply, I try to see - for myself and those I know - what it means to love, to forgive, to find meaning, to be sexual and spiritual, to pray, to form a happy family, to face my fears - without losing humour. Shall we have a look at what lies beneath the commonest yet most meaningful words that we use everyday?

You know as well as I do the thrill of opening a gift box. The book, of course, is hardly more than the ribbon around the box. The parcel - whether in mint condition or damaged in the mail - is life itself.

open it, and unwrap the amazing gifts one by one.You will find your name on each.

 

Why This Book?

Most of the contents of this book first appeared as articles. The enthusiastic response of readers - cutting across such dividing lines as age, nationality, race and religious affiliation - was one reason for bringing out this book.

The other reason is equally simple. In our quieter moments - at night, or in a bus or train, or after a heated argument, or when facing pain and uncertainty - most of us reflect on life’s “really real” questions, and seek greater clarity. As Sheila, a young artist, told me, “My friends and me - we do talk of the things that really matter, but we do it in informal settings, with close friends, drinking coffee or after a movie. We do have the most exciting discussions!”

This book addresses that type of interest and concern - to talk of the things that matter, but in a direct and informal way, in plain and possibly witty idiom. These are the issues that students have thrashed out with me, in calm or heated exchanges. These are the queries I hear from teachers who want to answer their students’ questions - and their own. Others - parents, counsellors, social workers - want to clarify these issues for themselves and those who seek their help.
Why the question - answer format? For clarity, directness and focus. Why these rather than other topics? Because these seem to be the “hot topics” people are most concerned about. Why the “Do it” section at the end? Because most people want to organize their life better, and wish they knew how.

Look at the contents. If the topics you see pass through your mind when you are alone, or come up in your conversation, or invite you to have a second look, you know for whom and why this book was written.

 


Book Review


If you were to pick the most precious gifts in life, what would they be? If you were to rank life’s most important tasks, what would the list look like? If you were given a chance to get answers to your ten most important questions, what would you ask? If you needed a blueprint to live life to the full, where would you look?

Do these questions interest you? Do they tug at your heartstrings? If so, A Closer Look is for you. This is the sort of book that can bring about a whole new perspective on life. In it, Fr. Joe Mannath, a regular columnist of the NL, takes up some of life’s most common - yet always puzzling - questions and explores them with stunning clarity and disarming honesty. He lays before the reader the things that really matter in life and nudges him/her to take a closer look not only at the issues under discussion but also at one’s whole life. An admirable and absorbing work.

The book is mostly a collection of 15 previously published articles, which have been substantially re - done for this volume. The book has three parts. Part I, Life’s Best Gifts, throws light on some of the central experiences of life, the kind of things that everyone thinks about: love, forgiveness, sexuality, prayer, the meaning of life, etc. Part II, Current Debates, takes the reader to a lively discussion on some of the hot topics of the day: politics, science and religion, patriotism, gender discrimination, spirituality. Part III, Just do it, contains some very practical tips on how to organize one’s life to get the best out of it.

In every article the reader will find fresh insights and new ways of looking at life and its challenges. The author has a way of getting to the heart of the matter without losing the focus, and with a lot of humour, too. The book is full of practical insights and contains concise answers in contemporary language to the many “really real” questions that people carry in their hearts. The thrust of the discussions, however, is not to close the issues but to open the minds.

In a brief review like this, one cannot do justice to all the whole range of topics dealt with in the volume. I limit myself to some passing remarks on just a few of them. The reflection on forgiveness (Forgive and Forget? I can’t!) is indeed an unforgettable piece; something that readers will want to read and re - read. The piece on humour (Humour is no joke!) is a serious invitation to recognize that a sense of humour and laughter are no laughing matter; they are vitally important for preserving one’s sanity and sanctity. The discussion on sexuality (The Fascinating Riddle of Sexuality) is a daringly beautiful presentation of a theme that is at once delicate and complex. The article on politics (Politics–Dirty Game or Serious Call?) is well thought out and deserves to be made compulsory reading for all our politicians  -  -  and the citizens who vote them to power. The piece on spirituality (The Inner Journey–Boring Escape or Thrilling Adventure?) is the most sensible and down - to - earth exposition of spirituality that I have read in recent years.
The book will be of great help to teachers, counsellors, parents and, in general, all those who, confronted by life’s challenges, seek greater clarity. It could also be an excellent guiding light for young people, setting out on life’s journey.

 -  K. J. Louis in 'The New Leader'

Contents:
Part I: Life’s Best Gifts

  1. Love, Life’s Most Precious gift

  2. Forgive and Forget? I Can’t!

  3. The Triple Secret of Happiness

  4. Facing Our Fears

  5. The  Fascinating Riddle of Sexuality

  6. Humour is No Joke

  7. For a Happy Family Life

  8. What’s the Use of Praying?

  9. What is the Meaning of (My) Life?

  10. Finding God in the Midst of a Busy Life

Part II: Current Debates:

  1. Politics - Dirty Game or Serious Call?

  2. Science and Religion

  3. Patriotism, True and False

  4. Gender Discrimination Harms Us All

  5. The Inner Journey - Boring Escape or Thrilling Adventure

Part III: Just Do it!
 

Sample Selection:
For a Happier Family Life


Of all the myriad influences that shape our lives, nothing probably matches the impact of our family. My family is also one of the basic building blocks that I cannot choose, or disown. We did not select our parents or our brothers and sisters. But we can choose how we relate to one another, and what to make of our years together. As we know from experience and observation, family life can be a bit of heaven or a bit of hell - or something worthwhile in between. What are the things we can do to make it reasonably happy?

Q1. I have very mixed feelings about family life. At times I think it is the nicest, most precious thing this side of heaven. At other times I ask myself: “Is any family happy?” What are your comments?

Both your feelings are understandable. Let me illustrate.
When my brother’s children were in school, it was a shock for them to discover that a number of their class mates did not enjoy spending time at home. In fact, several of them preferred to visit other class mates rather than be at home during vacations.

These class mates in their turn could not believe that my nephews and niece longed for their parents’ company - that their nicest, warmest, funniest times were in the company of their parents.

Both these reactions are found among family members - the family as the nicest place on earth, and the family as something to escape from.

Q2. Can you give us some practical tips for a happy family life?
I’ll try. The following tips are based on what I have observed and learned during my contacts with families - including my own. I shall divide these suggestions into do’s and don’ts.
First, the do’s:

(1) Do praise your children. A poised young working woman tells me: “I know that my sisters are prettier than I am. But this has never been a problem for me, because my mother always made me feel good about myself.” A lecturer in a college shares the main secret of her self - confidence: “My father always thought highly of me. He made me feel that I would be an asset to any man I would marry.”
Appreciate each child in his/her uniqueness, without comparing them (generally unfavourably) with your other children. Show appreciation for who they are and for what they do. Your appreciation means the world to them.

(2) Do respect your spouse. If a husband and wife want their children’s respect, they must first treat each other with evident love and respect. If a husband puts down the wife, or she talks ill of him to the children, both lose the children’s respect and trust.

(3) Do correct them (without humiliating them in public). This seems self - explanatory. Your children themselves will be shocked if you give in to all their whims and habits.

(4) Pray everyday - for your children and with them. What sustains many of us in our difficult moments is the sense of God we picked up from our parents.

(5) Train them to give and to make sacrifices. A wonderful man I know remembers how his mother trained him, at the age of seven, to do little services for his aged, bed - ridden uncle. That little boy grew up to be a gem of a human being - caring, generous and thoughtful.

(6) Spend time with your children. This is a big hurdle for many parents, especially for many men who have to work outside the home. But both you and your children need this time together. I remember hearing a four - year - old tell his father, who was on his way out: “Daddy, if you are not here, who will watch me play?” A very good question! In fact, one of the regrets a number of older people - especially men - have is that they did not spend enough time at home when the children were growing up. I think, for instance, of my friend Bill, a successful businessman. When a colleague of his own age succumbed to cancer, Bill took a good look at life. One of the decisions that followed: spend more time with wife and children.

Q3. What about the don’ts?
The don’ts would include the following:

(1) Don’t be partial: One of the things children resent most is partiality. This is something people remember (at times with bitterness) all their life. A sixty - year - old woman recalls her childhood this way: “My older sister was always preferred to me.” A mother or father may feel greater attraction or liking towards a particular son or daughter, but they should not discriminate among them in practice, like, buying better gifts for your favourite child, or praising one for the same thing for which you blamed another child, or showing special signs of predilection for one or two of your children.

(2) Don’t compare: “Why can’t you be like your elder brother? He is so smart.” This sort of comparison hurts, especially if it refers to talents. (“What a pity my daughter Priya is not as bright as her brother Anand.”)

(3) Don’t imitate your children: Don’t try to talk or dress like your children, especially if you are much older. Being close to your children means being with them physically and emotionally, available to help them in need. It does not mean that a middle - aged mother should wear the clothes that suit her teenage daughter, or use youth slang to sound “hep.”

(4) Don’t gossip: In some families, you never hear any gossip. The family has lots of happy moments being together, and does not find any need to discuss people to pass the time. In other families, unfortunately, as soon as guests leave the house, everyone starts discussing them. Children unthinkingly pick up such habits from grown - ups. One very sensible mother told her children: “There are so many nice things we can talk about and be happy. We do not discuss people.”

(5) Don’t measure the value of your friends and relatives by the money they have: Show the same warmth and respect to the poor cousin as to the rich nephew; visit the well - placed uncle as well as the sick and needy aunt. Or else, your own children will measure each other by income and status.

(6) Don’t ignore the poor: This again is something we learn from our parents . A class mate of mine who was very involved in working for the poor, shared with me one of his childhood memories. They had all finished their supper one day, except for his mother. Just then a poor man came by, asking for food. His mother took the food that she had kept for herself, gave it to the beggar, and went to bed without supper. Years later he asked her whether she remembered this incident. She didn’t. She must have done similar things many other times, without letting anyone else know.

Q4. Isn’t the situation of families today very different from earlier periods? The family today is both different from and similar to families in earlier ages. To start with the differences:

(1) Most families (especially among the educated and the better off) are smaller than before. This has both good and bad consequences. On the positive side, greater attention to each child, greater educational opportunities, greater training to independence, less burden on the earth’s resources. On the flip side, children who are used to getting more (attention, money or things) often become more egoistic and less willing to share; they miss much of the learning that would come from growing up with siblings.

(2) Because of the invasion of the media (TV, movies, radio, newspapers, magazines, videos, the computer and the Internet,…), there is much less control on what a child sees, hears and knows while growing up. Childhood today is far less protected than before.

(3) Where both parents work outside the home, the child spends much less time with the parents. In some families, the only time the whole family meets together is on weekends. For others, that occasion is the evening meal.

(4) Relationships between parents and children have become less authoritarian and more “democratic”. Many of today’s children and teenagers relate to their parents much more informally (teasing them, playing with them, or hugging or having fun) than the parents did to their parents.

(5) For a number of families, the question of the mother’s working outside the home is a thorny issue. On the one hand, many families want and even need that extra income, and many women want the financial independence and sense of achievement that comes from a professional life. One is not just Mrs. So - and - so, or mother of So - and - so. But in holding a full time job outside the home, many women find themselves under tough pressures: the situation of having to work both outside and inside the home, insensitive husbands who do not help in household chores (which they see as a “woman’s job”), the tension of not being able to be with one’s children as much as one likes,...

(6) Another noticeable trait of today’s families is this: With the rise in consumerism, there is an increasing pressure to buy, to own the latest gadgets and the most exclusive products. This is a demand that most families - except the very rich - find extremely difficult to cope with.

Q5. Are there also areas in which today’s families resemble families of earlier times?
There are, of course. Human nature, after all, does not change all that much, and our basic needs and expectations are more or less the same in different periods of history. To quote a few unchanging factors:

(1) Research, as well as common human experience, shows that the impact of the family, particularly of the parents, on our personality and achievement is undeniable. Children may drool over sports heroes or collect the pictures of their favourite movie stars. But no one matches the influence of mother and father on a person. In a survey I did for Friends Magazine, covering one thousand teenagers from ten centres in different parts of India, we found that the person most youngsters admired most was their mother or father.

(2) So, too, as counselling and therapy sessions testify, most of our deepest hurts come from our family. We are probably loved most, helped most and hurt most in our family relationships. Some of the scars are deep and hard to erase. . In fact, much counselling and psychotherapy deal with the traumas people suffered while they were growing up.

(3) Our earliest years shape us and the way we see the world as almost nothing else does. In those impressionable years, when we were at our most dependent and helpless, what others did or did not do for us affects us deeply.

Q6. What about the so - called “crisis of family life” that we hear about?
The talk about this crisis is largely a Western phenomenon, but some of the same problems are found here too.
To begin with, we must not make sweeping generalizations, like, “The family in the West is gone to the dogs,” “The Indian family is close - knit and strong,” “Young people today have no strong family values,” etc. All such statements contain a kernel of truth and much misinformation.
What is the kernel of truth?

This: With greater mobility, greater separation among family members for reasons of work, stronger impact of the mass media, and the rising impact of individualism, family ties have perhaps become more tenuous. This does not mean that there is any country or culture where the family is not important. A certain criticism of “family values” is even healthy: the family can become an egoistic unit, closed in on itself, unwilling to get involved in the needs of other relatives or neighbours or of society at large.

It is difficult to compare families in different countries. They differ in style and preferred values, but not in their sensed importance of family life. To give two examples, Indian (or Asian) families stress the family over the individual. There is less room (even physically!) for the individual. The son or daughter is often expected to yield to the parents’ wishes, e.g., in choosing the marriage partner. This is not generally the case in Europe or America. Or again, the Indian family controls the children more than the average Western family does. To quote a recent example, a group of professors who came to Chennai from Spain were surprised that parents expected young women of twenty - five, or even older, to be back home by 5 p.m. Again, our families are more “hierarchical”, theirs more democratic.
There are advantages and disadvantages in each system. Any style can be used to promote a person or to crush all individuality. All forms contain loving and selfish manifestations.

Q7. How can I grow up in a necessarily imperfect family and yet live without regrets?
No one is born in a perfect family. Nobody has perfect parents. Just because your parents were not up to the mark, or do not measure up to the example set by others’ parents, you are not destined to fail, or to waste your life on regrets. Laments and wishful thinking (“If only my parents had been like his parents,” “If only my mother had shown me more love,” “If only I had a father I can be proud of…”) are a colossal waste and lead us to lose the best we have - the present moment and all that we are blessed with. You probably do not know the pains and struggles of the families you so easily envy. They may even be envying you.

Calling a family happy is like saying that trees are green. Trees looks green from far. When you get close to them, you see that each tree has many shades of green, in addition to patches of grey and black and brown and white, as well as moth - eaten leaves and broken branches. There really are no perfectly green trees. So, too, with families.

You and I come from imperfect families, from which we received both tenderness and scars. With all its limitations, this messy, crazy, funny, loving, at times infuriating, often disappointing cluster of human beings living, eating, sleeping, fighting, loving, laughing, crying together is one of life’s most precious gifts. We may grumble and shout, but, by golly, it’s among the few things without which we would be totally lost. Don’t you agree?

For personal reflection:
1. What are the best gifts you have received from your family?
2. What are your pains and disappointments? What are you doing to get healed of them?
3. Would you like your new family to be like your original family? How? In what ways do you want it to be different?
4. Among the tips given for a happy family life, which do you find most useful for your situation?
5.
6. If you were to write to brief code of conduct for your family, what would it include?

 

This is what readers say:

“Very useful and extremely solid…Beautiful way of expressing profound truths in simple and interesting language.”

“The fascinating riddle of sexuality: a daringly beautiful piece!”

“The article on forgiveness is the BEST piece in the whole collection. It disturbs! I read it a number of times.”